7 Engagement Ring Mistakes Even Smart Shoppers Make
Choosing an engagement ring is one of the most meaningful, and expensive, purchases you’ll ever make. And yet, even smart, thoughtful shoppers still make mistakes that lead to regret, unnecessary stress, or designs that don’t hold up over time.
As a jewellery concierge and former diamond consultant, I’ve worked with hundreds of couples and clients in Calgary and throughout Western Canada. Here are seven mistakes I see even the savviest ring shoppers make… and how to avoid them.
1. Focusing Only on the Centre Stone
Source: GIA 4Cs Blog
The diamond (or gemstone) matters, but it’s not everything.
Smart shoppers often obsess over the 4 C’s, but forget to consider how the ring setting, band design, and overall proportions affect the final look and wearability.
CONCIERGE TIP
A beautiful stone in the wrong setting can look awkward or wear poorly.
Consider how it all works together, not just the specs on paper.
| Curious about proportions and styling? Learn about The Refined Experience.
2. Choosing a Trend Instead of a Timeless Fit
Source: Instagram
Oval solitaires, ultra-thin bands, and hidden halos are popular on Instagram. But, they’re not right for everyone.
What looks stunning in a photo might not suit your hand shape, lifestyle, or long-term vision. For example, ultra-thin bands often lack the structural strength to hold up to daily wear over time.
CONCIERGE TIP
Trends fade, but your ring is forever.
Choose what feels like you, not just what’s popular right now.
3. Underestimating the Importance of Lifestyle
Even smart shoppers forget to think about how the ring will function day to day. Do you work with your hands? Wear gloves regularly? Travel often?
Certain designs (like high-set solitaires or delicate pavé bands) may not be practical for you, and can require more frequent repairs or replacements.
CONCIERGE TIP
Style is important… but so is comfort and durability in an engagement ring.
Choose something that fits your real life, not just the proposal photos.
4. Thinking Custom Always Means More Expensive
This is a big one.
Many people assume custom rings will always break the bank. In reality, custom designed jewellery can actually help you prioritize what matters most… and skip what doesn’t.
One past client came to me with a $8,000 budget and left with a custom design that used higher quality materials than any of the retail options they’d seen, and felt more like their story.
Done well, custom can offer better value, better materials, and more personalization than retail options at the same price point.
CONCIERGE TIP
Custom isn’t just for luxury budgets. It’s about creating something meaningful with expert guidance.
| Explore if custom is right for you: Custom Jewellery Consultations
5. Going It Alone (Without a Trusted Advocate)
Even the most confident shoppers can feel overwhelmed by the language, pressure, and options in traditional jewellery stores. And while salespeople may be helpful, they’re still working for the store (not for you).
CONCIERGE TIP
A jewellery concierge works for you, not a brand.
I guide you through the buying or custom process with clarity and honesty. No commission. No pressure.
6. Rushing the Timeline
Smart doesn’t always mean patient.
I’ve seen couples fall in love with a custom idea just weeks before their engagement date, only to be disappointed by tight turnarounds or missed details.
Most custom rings take 4-8 weeks minimum, depending on the complexity of the design, time of year, and jeweller availability.
CONCIERGE TIP
Start early, even if you’re not ready to buy.
Research, consultations, and revisions take time. You want to enjoy the process, not rush it.
7. Forgetting Who It’s For
This sounds obvious, but I’ve seen clients unintentionally buy rings that reflect what their friends, parents, or Instagram feed would love; not what their partner would.
The best ring isn’t the biggest or trendiest. It’s the one that reflects your partner’s style, lifestyle, and values.
CONCIERGE TIP
If you’re unsure, work with a jewellery concierge to define your partner’s style (or include them in part of the process without ruining the surprise).
| Let’s talk about your partner’s style: Book your Discovery Call.
Final Thoughts: You Don’t Have to Navigate This Alone
Shopping for an engagement ring should be exciting, not overwhelming. Whether you’re going custom, buying retail, or exploring both, I help you avoid costly mistakes and make decisions with clarity and confidence.
| Want expert support without pressure?
| Book a free Discovery Call
| Or explore Custom Jewellery Consultations
✨ Ready to find jewellery that actually feels like you?
👉 Follow along on Instagram @refined.by.robyn