Why You Shouldn’t Wear Cheap Jewellery (Even If It Looks Good at First)
We’ve all been there… tempted by a sparkly piece of jewellery in a store window or Instagram ad that promises style at a “can’t miss” price. And at first glance, it seems like a no-brainer. Cute. Cheap. Done.
But here’s what most people don’t consider: cheap jewellery often comes with hidden costs. Not just financially, but in quality, comfort, and long-term wear.
As a jewellery concierge in Calgary, I help clients across Western Canada build intentional jewellery wardrobes they actually wear and love. And one of the first things I help people unlearn? That “affordable” doesn’t always mean “better value.”
Here’s what you need to know before buying another fast-fashion piece or mystery-metal ring.
The Hidden Costs of Cheap Jewellery
Cheap jewellery isn’t always a bargain. Whether it’s poorly plated, mass-produced, or made from mystery metals, there’s a reason that $25 necklace doesn’t last.
It Tarnishes Fast
Most inexpensive jewellery is gold-plated over base metals like brass or copper. These pieces tarnish quickly and can’t be polished. The finish often wears off within weeks (or even days), especially if exposed to sweat, water, or lotion.
It Can Cause Skin Irritation
Nickel is one of the most common base-metals found in cheap jewellery, and it’s a frequent cause of rashes, green stains, or itchiness. If you’ve ever noticed your fingers turning green after wearing a ring, this is likely why.
It Breaks Easily
Flimsy clasps, loose prongs, and poor band construction mean cheap jewellery is more prone to breaking. Even if you’re able to repair, the cost of repair can often be higher than the cost of the piece.
Real Value = Cost Per Wear
That $20 ring that tarnishes and is unwearable after 3 wears? It’s actually more expensive than the $200 piece you wear 200 times.
When I work with clients during a Style Audit & Jewellery Wardrobe Edit, we look at cost per wear and durability.
The best jewellery pieces aren’t the trendiest. They’re the ones that last.
Why “Affordable” Pieces Rarely Hold Up
Inexpensive doesn’t always mean “bad,” but it often means corners were cut somewhere in the process: materials, manufacturing, or ethical sourcing.
Watch out for:
Gold or silver plated pieces with ultra-thin coatings that wear off quickly
Mystery metal alloys with no clear disclosure of what you’re actually wearing
“Trendy” styles mass-produced to sell fast
Factory-made pieces not designed for daily use or lasting comfort
If you’re constantly replacing jewellery, that adds up quickly (in both money and frustration).
Should You Ever Buy Costume Jewellery?
Absolutely… if it’s intentional.
Costume or plated jewellery can be fun for a special occasion or event. But if you love the look and find yourself reaching for that style often? It’s a sign to invest in a high-quality version that will last.
Use costume jewellery as a trail run, not a forever piece.
| Want help upgrading your favourites? Book a free Discovery Call to start your custom or curated upgrade plan.
What to Look For Instead
Here’s what I recommend when clients are ready to move away from fast fashion jewellery:
Gold, sterling silver, or platinum. These metals can be worn every day and won’t tarnish like plated alternatives.
Hypoallergenic pieces made without nickel or other irritants.
Well-constructed designs with secure clasps, smooth edges, and thoughtful details.
Versatile, wearable styles that work with your everyday wardrobe.
If you’re not sure where to begin, start with a small upgrade (like a pair of everyday earrings, a signature ring, or a minimal chain necklace). Choose one piece you’ll reach for daily, and build from there.
| Not sure whether you should buy gold or silver jewellery? Read How to Style Jewellery Based on Your Skin Tone.
Your Jewellery Should Reflect Your Life (Not Just Your Outfit)
Jewellery isn’t just an accessory. It’s part of how you move through the world. It should reflect your personal style, but also your comfort, values, and lifestyle.
That’s why I help clients build intentional collections that last. Not drawers full of forgotten pieces, tarnished chains, or broken clasps. Whether you’re building your capsule collection or looking to upgrade your everyday staples, I’m here to help you shop smarter, not just more often.
| Curious how we work together? Explore The Refined Experience.
Final Thought: You Deserve Jewellery That Feels as Good as It Looks
You don’t need a jewellery box full of “almost-right” pieces. You need a few great ones that feel good to wear, and still look good next year (and the year after that).
Let’s build that kind of collection together.
| Explore Personal Jewellery Shopping Services
| Or book your free Discovery Call.
✨ Ready to find jewellery that actually feels like you?
👉 Follow along on Instagram @refined.by.robyn